How a Play About 1,000,006 Brilliant Things Can Rewire Your Brain: The Story of 'Every Brilliant Thing'

Cover

The Play That Begins with a Question

Imagine you walk into a theatre. The lights are low. A person walks on stage, looks at the audience, and says something surprising: "Hi. My mom tried to kill herself today. So I started this list. A list of everything brilliant about the world. Everything worth living for."

So begins Every Brilliant Thing, a play written by Duncan Macmillan with Jonny Donahoe. The list starts small and childlike. Number 1: Ice cream. Number 2: Water fights. Number 3: Staying up late and watching old movies with the sound turned down. But here's the twist: you are not just watching this story. You are part of it. Before the show begins, audience members are handed slips of paper with items from the list written on them. Throughout the performance, the actor calls out a number, and whoever has that card stands up, reads their "brilliant thing" aloud, and sits back down.

It sounds quirky. It sounds risky. And it absolutely works. What could be dismissed as a gimmick becomes the heart of the experience. The audience becomes a chorus, a community, a group of people agreeing, moment by moment, that the world is full of things worth staying for. What if the most powerful tool for addressing depression wasn't a lecture or a clinical diagnosis, but a shared, imperfect list of small joys, performed live?

Why Theatre? The Unique Power of Live Performance

You might be thinking: couldn't this just be a book, or a TED Talk, or a Netflix special? What does theatre add that a screen can't replicate?

The answer lies in something psychologists call shared presence. When you watch a recorded video, you are alone with the content. When you sit in a theatre, you are breathing the same air as the actor and the stranger next to you. Your nervous systems start to sync up. Laughter ripples through the crowd. Silences feel heavier. When someone next to you cries, you feel the permission to cry too.

This is crucial for conversations about mental health. Depression is an isolating illness. It convinces you that you are alone in your struggle. Live theatre breaks that spell. It makes the invisible pain of depression visible, and it makes the private act of struggling into something public and shared. Watching Every Brilliant Thing in a room full of strangers, you realize you are part of a temporary community. You are all holding space for a difficult topic together. No streaming service can replicate the feeling of a hundred strangers collectively deciding to participate in an act of hope. It is a muscle that gets strengthened only when we flex it together.

The Core Idea: Collecting Small Joys

Let's talk about that list. "Ice cream. The taste of Crayola crayons. The smell of old books. Finding a twenty-dollar bill in your pocket. The first sip of coffee in the morning." On paper, it might look like a scrapbook of sentimental fluff. But the play is doing something much deeper.

The protagonist isn't making the list because life is easy. He is making it because life is unbearably hard for someone he loves. The list is a survival mechanism. It is a child's desperate attempt to construct a reason to stay alive in the face of overwhelming darkness. This taps into a psychological principle called savoring — the act of consciously directing your attention toward positive experiences and prolonging the feeling they give you.

The play is, essentially, a gratitude practice dressed up as a comedy show. And the research backs this up. Psychologists have found that people who regularly write down things they are grateful for report higher levels of optimism, better sleep, and stronger social connections. But the play adds a crucial layer: it doesn't pretend the list is a cure. The narrator tells us plainly that the list didn't save his mother. It didn't erase her pain. What it did was give him a way to keep going. It trained his brain to scan the world for the good stuff, even when the bad stuff was overwhelming.

This isn't "toxic positivity." It is something far more honest: a stubborn, fragile, and deeply human refusal to give up. The list is not a denial of pain. It is a weapon against it.

How Interactive Stories Change Our Brains

If the list is the heart of the play, the audience participation is the engine that makes it run. By handing the audience a role, the play does something powerful: it transforms passive viewers into active participants.

When you are given a slip of paper and a number, you make a silent commitment. You are now part of the cast. Your brain shifts from a state of passive observation to one of active agency. You are responsible for your line. You have skin in the game. This changes how deeply you process the experience.

Neuroscientists have studied this phenomenon. When you are actively doing something, your brain encodes the memory differently and more strongly than when you just watch it happen. It's the difference between watching a video of someone baking a cake and actually mixing the batter yourself.

In Every Brilliant Thing, when you stand up and say your line — "Number 43: The feeling of crisp, clean sheets" — you aren't just hearing a story about optimism. You are performing an act of optimism in front of a room full of strangers. You are publicly committing to the idea that this small thing matters. That act of commitment is powerful. It transforms a message you heard into a truth you practiced. You walk out of the theatre not just having watched someone else's story, but having participated in building a shared reality where joy is worth cataloging.

From Stage to Community: Real Impact Around the World

Since its premiere at the Edinburgh Fringe Festival, Every Brilliant Thing has been performed on almost every continent. It has been staged in intimate black-box theatres, on Broadway, in high school gymnasiums, and in hospital wards.

The real-world impact goes beyond the standing ovations. Mental health organizations like Mind in the UK and various suicide prevention hotlines have partnered with theatres to stage the show. Post-show discussions often become the most important part of the evening. Audience members stay for an hour, sharing their own lists, their own stories, their own struggles. It creates a doorway into a conversation that many people desperately want to have but don't know how to start.

Universities have incorporated the play into their psychology and performing arts curriculums. Drama therapists have used it as a model for how art can facilitate healing conversations. It is not a replacement for clinical therapy — the creators are very clear about this — but it acts as a powerful bridge. It reduces stigma not by lecturing people about it, but by making the experience of talking about mental health feel safe, communal, and even joyful.

What People Get Wrong: It's Not Just a Feel-Good Show

A lot of people misunderstand Every Brilliant Thing before they see it. Let's clear up the most common misconceptions.

"It trivializes depression." This is the biggest one. The concern is that a list of "ice cream and water fights" is an insult to the depth of clinical depression. In practice, the exact opposite happens. The play honors the struggle by showing how hard it is to find those small joys when the darkness closes in. The list isn't presented as a magic cure. It is presented as a desperate, fragile, and heroic effort. The laughter in the room is always tinged with the knowledge of what the list is fighting against.

"It's only for people who are depressed." Not at all. The play is for anyone who has ever loved someone who was suffering, or who simply needs a reminder of why the world is worth sticking around for. It is a play about being human.

"The audience participation is awkward." It sounds terrifying, but the show is designed to be deeply gentle with its audience. You never have to improvise. You just have to read what's on your card. The actor guides the room with warmth and humor. The risk you take is small, but the reward — the feeling of being part of something — is huge.

"It replaces therapy." This is the most important distinction. Every Brilliant Thing is therapeutic, meaning it makes people feel seen and connected. But it is not a substitute for professional help. The creators have always been careful to frame the show as art that sparks conversation, not as a medical intervention. It points you toward the help you might need, but it doesn't pretend to be the help itself.

Next Steps: Dive Deeper into Theatre and Mental Health

If Every Brilliant Thing opened a door for you, there is a rich world of art and psychology waiting on the other side.

If you want more plays that tackle mental health with honesty and humanity, seek out Next to Normal, a rock musical that explores bipolar disorder and the toll it takes on a family, or Dear Evan Hansen, which dives into social anxiety, grief, and the desperate human need for connection.

If you are interested in the psychology behind the list, look into Behavioral Activation, a core component of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT). The basic idea is that doing positive activities, even when you don't feel like it, can shift your mood. The list is essentially a Behavioral Activation project. You can also explore Narrative Therapy, which uses storytelling as a way to reframe personal struggles.

And if you want to bring this experience into your own life, consider starting your own list. It doesn't have to be for an audience. It can just be for you. The act of writing down one brilliant thing each day has been shown to shift brain chemistry over time. Give it a week. See what you notice.

Key Takeaways

Small joys are a practice, not a platitude. Actively collecting moments of beauty and gratitude is a psychological strategy backed by research, not just feel-good advice.
Shared experience breaks isolation. Watching a difficult topic in a live theatre creates a temporary community that reduces the stigma and loneliness of mental health struggles.
Active participation creates lasting change. When you physically take part in a story — even just reading a line from a card — your brain encodes the experience more deeply than passive consumption.
Art is not therapy, but it can be a bridge. Every Brilliant Thing opens the door for important conversations, but it does not replace professional mental health care.
The list is for everyone. Whether you are struggling yourself or love someone who is, the act of noticing what is brilliant about the world is a muscle we can all strengthen together.